reviews
   
links  
   
forum  
   
contact  
   
home  
   
Picture Book Reviews

The Sweetest Fig
Elephants Aloft
Two Old Potatoes and Me.
My Friend Rabbit
A Caldecott Celebration: six artists and their paths to the Caldecott Medal.

Van Allsburg, Chris. The Sweetest Fig. 1993. Houghton Mifflin Company. ISBN 0395673461

Appropriate for ages 5 to 9. A greedy and unsympathetic dentist treats neither his dog, nor his patients with great kindness. One day an old woman pleads with him as he is leaving his office to help her with a terrible toothache. Thinking of the extra money, he accepts. When he is done, the woman offers him two figs in payment for his work. Enraged, he shouts at her and stomps back home to his little dog. He goes ahead and has one of the figs for supper that night, and it is exquisite. He dreams and then the next morning, much to his consternation, his dream happens. Excited, he realizes that the other fig will likely have the same magic. He trains himself for days to dream of money, and finally, he thinks he is ready to eat the second fig. What happens next is fitting and will satisfy a reader’s sense of justice. The illustrations are grainy and dreamlike, which enhance the tone of the story. They done realistically though, and the expressions and actions very well illustrated. This Bluebonnet nominee will appeal to older children’s sense of fairness and those children who can recall a few dreams that they wish would come true.

top

Appelt, Kathi. Elephants Aloft. Illustrated by Keith Baker. 1993. Harcourt Brace & Co. ISBN 015225384x

Appropriate for ages 1 to 5. Two young elephants receive a letter from their aunt who misses them. Their journey to visit their aunt in Rwanda takes them over, under, around and much more. A long trip in a hot air balloon by two elephants is fanciful, amusing, and will appeal to a child’s sense of adventure. The illustrations have great texture and are adept at teaching relational concepts. One word per page leaves the story of the journey entirely to the pictures. Large and lovely illustrations reminiscent of Babar will delight preschool children with the wealth of details to look at over the course of the journey. Toddlers and older babies will have a delightful example of prepositions, one to a two page spread. They will also enjoy the bright colors and happy elephants.

top

Coy, John. 2003. Two Old Potatoes and Me. Illustrated by Carolyn Fisher. Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN 0375821805.

Appropriate for ages 5 to 7. A girl finds two old potatoes sprouting in the back of a cupboard at her dad’s house. “GROSS!” she exclaims, but her dad stops her from throwing them away. Instead, they call up her grandfather who advises them on how to grow potato plants. They start their potato garden in her father’s back yard and take care of the plants all summer until potatoes are ready to be dug up. The issue of divorce is handled subtly and sensitively, but the fascinating part of the story for children will be how they harvested so many potatoes when they only started with two. The illustrations are vibrant and in a naïve, collage-like style. The text is sometimes merged with the illustrations, and often wiggles around the page. A great addition is the recipe in the back of the book for mashed potatoes, simple enough for a young child to participate in and for even a novice chef to follow.

top

Rohmann, Eric. My Friend Rabbit. 2002. Roaring Brook Press. ISBN 0761315357

Appropriate for ages 3 to 7. Poor Rabbit! And poor Mouse too, for it’s hard to be friends with someone who is never far from trouble. But friendship does persevere and bring many interesting and sometimes improbable adventures. The illustrations practically dance with life and humor. Many times in this work, the text supports the illustrations, leaving the bulk of the storytelling to lie with the pictures. The story moves along briskly and there are several pages without any text at all, but they are very eloquent and amusing. The two-page spread of the culmination of Rabbit’s plan turns the book on its side and one can practically see the animals wobbling and straining with effort. It is no wonder that these illustrations won the Caldecott for 2003. The story is engaging and you find yourself wondering how these two characters became friends, and what other wild mishaps Rabbit has brought into Mouse’s life.

Children will delight in the humor of the ideas Rabbit is inspired with to help his friend as well as the brilliantly illustrated scenes that speak for themselves.

top

Marcus, Leonard S. 1998. A Caldecott Celebration: six artists and their paths to the Caldecott Medal. Walker and Company. ISBN 0802786561.

This nonfiction look at six artists that have won the Caldecott Medal is interesting and insightful. Taking one artist from each of the decades that the Caldecott has been given, the book gives biographical information, preliminary sketches, some quotes from the illustrators, what happened to the illustrator after they won the award and other books illustrated by each winner featured. The titles featured are Make Way for Ducklings, by Robert McCloskey, Cinderella; or, The Little Glass Slipper by Marcia Brown, Where the Wild Things Are, by Maurice Sendak, Sylvester and the Magic Pebble, by William Steig, Jumanji by Chris Van Allsburg, and Tuesday by David Wiesner. The book also lists all Caldecott Medal winners from the first given in 1938 to 1998. Seeing the preliminary sketches and versions of the illustrations of these classic books is intriguing and illuminates how much work it took to complete and complement the story in these picture books. Some of the artists were also the authors of the books, and some are the illustrators only.

top